Showing posts with label federalism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label federalism. Show all posts

Autonomous greetings towards Federalism! Onward to an autonomous Cordillera leading to a Federal Republic of the Philippines

>> Monday, January 11, 2021



Let us fervently greet 2021 with new beginnings, of inspiring perspectives and resolve that make our communities, our country meet the challenges of economic, political and social conditions towards autonomous regional and federal realities.
 
Regional autonomy is federalism, the capacity to regionally exist based on political self-determination and economic potentials fueled by human resources and moved by respective cultural, local peculiarities.
 
Autonomy is federalism within a national republic that every regional state shall move, freely govern and exist on its capacity and have the opportunity for economic growth brought about by the equitable sharing of government wealth and resources resulting to faster delivery of services and benefits to its citizenry.
 
Regional autonomy is federalism that regional constituents shall make this happen inherently and politically conscious that change can happen from the present unitary form of government to decentralized regional states that make services and opportunities accessible and closer to the people.
 
For what is government but a government of the people, for the people and by the people.
 
In the Cordillera, we can make this happen. Ingrained in our cultural ways of independence and autonomy, this resolve to move our very own resources- natural and human- towards a politically self-determining Cordillera of its economic potentials and social realities that a federal, regional autonomous Cordillera state can be realized.
 
This we can realize in a government imprinted with a national Constitution that is republican and democratic and by the spirit of the law respects and recognizes resolves of its citizenry to make better and people- friendly conditions to carve systems responsive to its very own people.
 
Together as a people, we make this happen.
 
Onward to the making of a federal and autonomous Cordillera! Onward to the creation of federal states in a republican and democratic nation. Onward to a new Republic! Matago-tago tako am-in!

From the:
Alliance of Volunteers for Cordillera Autonomy (AVCA)
Philippine National Coalition for Revolutionary Government towards Federalism (PNCRGF)
Mayor Rodrigo Roa Duterte-Cordillera Administrative Region - National Executive Coordinating Committee (MRRD-CAR-NECC)

Read more...

DILG-Abra pushes constitutional reform

>> Sunday, January 12, 2020


BANGUED, Abra -- The Dept. of Interior and Local Government– Abra rolled out its CORE provincial roadshow gathering leaders of barangays, province and representatives from national government agencies, academe, and civil society organizations.
The provincial roadshow, which is in line with President Rodrigo Roa Duterte’s political agenda and campaign for a Constitutional Reform (CORE), was held at the Divine Word College of Bangued Gymnasium with over 2,000 participants.
DILG-Abra Provincial Director Millicent CariƱo said the activity was a venue for convergence to create a dialogue between the government and the people about the advocacy on CORE. 
CariƱo discussed the four pillars of CORE which are  “Pagyamanin ang Probinsiya, Paluwagin ang Metro Manila”; “Gobyerno para sa Tao, Hindi Para sa Trapo”; “Bukas na Ekonomiya nang Lahat may Pagasa”, and “Bagong Konstitusyon para sa Bagong Henerasyon.”
In her message conveyed by Provincial Board Member Antonio Dayag, Governor Maria Jocelyn Bernos  said she  fully supports reform in the Constitution which will potentially lead to the realization of regional autonomy.
“The Provincial Government of Abra is committed to support a constitutional reform and the pursuit of our regional autonomy,” she said.
Dayag urged the barangays to be a part of this movement and re-echo the advocacy in their respective areas.
Abra Representative Joseph Sto. NiƱo Bernos acknowledged the participants for attending the activity as he assured that he will give full attention to the queries of the Abrenians on CORE.
“I’m here to listen and be open to all your queries, suggestions and concerns for me to raise up at the Congress,” Bernos said.
Earlier this month, Bernos and his fellow Cordillera congressmen filed House Bill 5687 seeking for the establishment of the Autonomous Region of Cordillera. 
“The eventual passage of this bill will be the first step in realizing our dreams of a united, peaceful, prosperous and distinctively unique community that our forefathers dreamt for us,” Bernos said in his official Facebook page. (JDP/CAGT- PIA-CAR, Abra).

Read more...

DILG rolls out constitutional reform roadshow in Ilocos Sur

>> Sunday, December 8, 2019


By Mar T Supnad

VIGAN CITY, Ilocos Sur– The Dept. of  Interior and Local Government in the Ilocos rolled out Constitutional Reform’s (CoRe) provincial roadshow dubbed “Balangayan 2019 Constitutional Roadshow” recently here at the Vigan City Convention Center. 
The DILG, in coordination with the Center for Federalism and Constitutional Reform (CFCR), conducted the CoRe roadshows nationwide in the pursuit of raising public awareness and secure substantial public support on the need to reform the present Constitution. 
Earlier, the DILG has created the CFCR to push the campaign for federalism. 
The CFCR will act as the central office in the production and distribution of campaign materials, such as pamphlets, presentations, and posters to be distributed online and offline to barangays nationwide.
Willy De Vera of the DILG in the Ilocos and regional project officer of the CFCR said the main highlight of the provincial roadshows was the discussion of the new version of the CORE to make the proposed government set-up easily understandable especially to the marginalized.
CoRe has four major objectives or pillars of messaging: Pagyamanin ang probinsya, paluwagin ang Metro Manila(Enriching the province, outspan Metro Manila); Gobyerno para sa tao, hindi para sa trapo(Government for the people, not for the traditional politician); Bukas na ekonomiya nang lahat ay may pag-asa(Hope for open economy for all); and Bagong konstitusyon para sa bagong henerasyon(New constitution for the new generation).
Its priority concerns would include providing more opportunities for the provinces to develop, elect leaders who care for their constituents and further bring the government closer to the people.
“Among the activities of the provincial roadshows in Region 1 are CoRe media briefing, town hall meeting, convention campaign with the leaders and members of the multi-sectoral group, and CoRe talk with the students,” said De Vera.
The regional offices of the DILG are tasked to implement the massive information and dissemination of the project with the assistance of the regional and provincial offices of the Philippine Information Agency nationwide.
The series of events take its cue from the “Dagyaw” concept—serving as an avenue for the participants to delve into government’s efforts on uplifting the lives and welfare of the people through informing them about the various government projects that are in line for them. 
In Ilocos Region, the Balangayan 2019 Constitutional Roadshow was conducted in the provinces of Pangasinan on October 20-23 and in Ilocos Norte last November 14-15.

Read more...

Lower House federalism bill ‘dead on arrival’

>> Monday, December 17, 2018


EDITORIALS


The House of Representatives on Dec. 11 approved on third and final reading its draft constitution that seeks to shift to a federal form of government.
Voting 224-22 with three abstentions, the Lower House passed the ‘Resolution of Both Houses No. 15,’ penned by House Speaker Gloria Arroyo.
The proposal seeks to remove the term limits for members of the Congress and the 1987 Constitution’s anti-political dynasty provision.
The bill also wants the president and vice president to come from the same party, each serving a term of four years and will be eligible for one reelection.
The proposal also seeks to bring back the two-party system and to require elected officials to have a college degree
The Lower House was able to meet the requirement that three-fourths of the total number of lawmakers must vote in favor of the bill for it to be passed.
But its chances of getting signed into law remain bleak, with senators saying it would be ‘dead on arrival’ at the Senate.
Meanwhile, the Dept. of Interior and Local Government is setting for next year an information campaign on the benefits of coming up with a federalist government for this country.
Pundits are saying federalism would not be accomplished within the term of President Duterte.
That remains to be seen as this administration with an unpredictable President had been known to pull surprises.

Lowering government workers’ retirement age

Here is interesting news for government workers. The House of Representatives has passed on final reading the measure lowering the optional retirement age of government workers from 60 to 56 years old.
Two hundred and six lawmakers voted in favor of House Bill 8683 on Dec. 11.
If enacted, government workers will have the option to terminate their employment even before they reach 60 years old, without substantial loss to their monthly income.
The bill amends Section 13-A of Republic Act 8291, or the “Government Service Insurance System (GSIS) Act of 1997,” by providing that government workers who have reached the age of 56 years may file for retirement and be entitled to old-age pension for life from the GSIS.
Authors of the bill are Representatives Antonio Tinio, France Castro, Rodel Batocabe, Alfredo Garbin Jr., and Maria Carmen Zamora, among others. If enacted, this would be a boon for government workers.

Read more...

Alvarado pushes federalism, says it can solve flooding in Bulacan

>> Tuesday, October 9, 2018


By Freddie Velez


CITY OF MALOLOS, Bulacan — “As long as our country is in the unitary form of government, we are not going to progress, so we should support the federal form of government that is being pushed by President Rodrigo Duterte.”
               In these words, Governor Wilhelmino M. Sy-Alvarado spelled out his strong support for federalism as the key for strengthening local governments and allowing them to deliver their respective areas to progress.
Alvarado cited the problem of flooding in Bulacan and the solution promised by the creation of mini dams in Nueva Ecija and Candaba swamp to prevent backflooding through the coastal areas.
“Under the federal form of government hindi na kailangan pang ipaalam sa itaas ang mahalagang proyekto tulad ng pagpapagawa ng mini dams ng taga Nueva Ecija at Pampanga sa Candaba dahil kaya na nilang magdesisyon para sa kapakanan ng lalawigan at mamamayan (there would be no need to have projects like mini dams for Nueva Ecija and Candaba, Pampanga approved by the national government because these may be decided by the provincial government for its people),” he said.
He said, while currently being under the presidential unitary form of government, the decision will be coming from the national government and provinces and localities will only be receivers of big-ticket projects.
“We can only propose because we are under a presidential unitary system. Decisions will be coming from the national government and will pass through Congress,” he explained.
Under a federal set-up, Alvarado believes proposals from the local government can be acted on by the local government in order to have them implemented. “We are the ones who do the job so it’s easier to solve the problems below,” he said.


Read more...

Federalism and what Filipinos need to know

>> Tuesday, August 7, 2018


BEHIND THE SCENES
Alfred P. Dizon

SAN FERNANDO CITY, La Union – As the government pushes for federalism, people are left wondering what this animal is all about. Despite all the news articles and sound bites on the matter, the average guy is left wondering, what’s in it for me?  
I was in San Fernando, thanks to an invitation of National Economic Development Authority Cordillera director Milagros Rimando to attend a conference on Cordillera autonomy and federalism and somehow, got some insight on the topics. 
Undersecretary Ryan Estevez of the Presidential Legislative Liaison Office (PLLO) expounded on federalism and how it would benefit the country.
He said President Rodrigo Duterte is an ardent advocate of federalism. Long before he decided to run, Duterte made rounds in the country to promote it. It was during these listening tours that he would float “if I were president” scenarios, which kept people guessing whether he would run or not.
When he finally decided to run, one of the reasons Duterte said prompted him to do so was that he was asked by his party, Partido Demokratiko Pilipino-Lakas ng Bayan (PDP-Laban), to carry the torch of federalism.
As explained by Estevez, Duterte’s pitch for it mainly involves two things: economic development not just for Metro Manila but for all the regions and peace, particularly in the south.

In a nutshell, what is federalism? Estevez said currently, the Philippines employs a unitary form of government with much of the power — decisions, policies, and programs — emerging from the central government.

Under federalism, however, power is divided or shared between the central government and local state governments.
Countries that employ a federal system of government includes the United States, Australia, Austria, Germany, Ethiopia, Brazil, Canada, Malaysia, India, and Mexico, among others.
An article by Levi A. So of phil.com says in the US, the national government has sole power or authority to print money, declare war, maintain the armed forces, enter into treaties with foreign governments, regulate interstates and international trade, and establish a postal system.
A power that states have, meanwhile, is to establish their own local governments. The power to tax, regulate business, set up courts, and build and maintain roads, among others, are shared by the national government and the local state government.

The argument of those pushing for federalism in the Philippines is that budget and fiscal autonomy have been a long-standing issue among local government units (LGUs) in the country, according to political analyst Jan Robert Go, assistant professor of political science at the University of the Philippines Diliman.

And most of the time, programs of the national government are "downloaded" to lower-income municipalities without the benefit of evaluating whether they are applicable and sustainable, he added.
One contention of federalism advocates is that major tax revenues are turned over to the national government.
So says, the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) collects national internal revenue taxes which include income tax, estate and donor's taxes, value-added tax, other percentage taxes, excise taxes, documentary stamp taxes, and such other taxes that may be imposed and collected by the BIR.
The pooled collection of national internal revenue taxes is split 60-40, with 60 percent going to the national government and 40 percent to the LGUs through the internal revenue allotment or IRA. This distribution of the IRA is also contested by federalism advocates.
In one interview, Duterte said it was unfair that what Davao City gets from the IRA wasn't even at par compared to the amount it remits to the national government.
LGUs are seen as the primary service providers but if funds are lacking, these services may be difficult to run and be provided to the public, Go said.
There have been attempts in the past to raise the IRA share given to local governments. One of which was by Duterte's party mate, PDP-Laban founder and former Sen. Aquilino Pimentel Jr., who wanted it raised to 50 percent.
Attempts were also made to include in the IRA the tariff and duties collected by the Bureau of Customs to increase the share that LGUs would be getting.

Is federalism the road to economic growth in poorer regions?

Duterte as the first Mindanaoan president and having served as Davao City mayor for nearly two decades is seen as someone who understands the issue well.
He has described Metro Manila as "imperial" and has even refused to stay at MalacaƱang, saying that it is a symbol of oppression.
Federalists lament the big share Metro Manila gets compared to other regions.
A look at the 2016 national budget showed that Metro Manila got a 14.27 percent share with P428.5 billion, excluding the budget for the Office of the President, Office of the Vice President and Congress which are based in the capital region.
Meanwhile, Luzon got 20.94 percent with P628.3 billion, Visayas got 9.94 percent with P298.3 billion, and Mindanao got 13.23 percent with P396.9 billion.
Out of the more than 100.98 million population in the country, 12.75 percent of the people are found in the densely-populated Metro Manila. Luzon, excluding Metro Manila, accounts for 44.16 percent of the population followed by Mindanao at 23.9 percent and Visayas at 19.18 percent.
Duterte hasn't laid out how his proposed shift to federalism would go about, but in one campaign rally he said that LGUs can keep most of their income. For every P100, the LGU would get P70 and the P30 would go to the national government, he said.
He also has yet to detail how states will be divided. But under Joint Resolution No. 10 proposed in 2008 by then Sen. Pimentel, he suggested the creation of 11 federal states out of the existing political subdivisions of the country with Metro Manila as the federal administrative region akin to Washington D.C. of the United States.

Will it bring peace to Mindanao? Duterte argues that federalism is primarily about peace.

Poverty is seen as one of the roots of armed rebellion, considered as a national security threat by the Office of the Presidential Adviser on the Peace Process. Likewise, historical neglect and injustice are seen as factors behind the emergence of secessionist groups in Mindanao.
Philippine Statistics Authority data showed that for the first semester of 2015, 11 of the 20 poorest provinces in the country are in Mindanao. These are Lanao del Sur, Sulu, Sarangani, Bukidnon, Maguindanao, Sultan Kudarat, Zamboanga del Norte, Agusan del Sur, North Cotabato, Lanao del Norte, and Camiguin.
Go said that it is possible for federalism to bring peace in Mindanao but warned against making it appear like the ultimate solution.
"Insofar as autonomy and self-government are concerned, perhaps federalism may provide the framework," he said. "But I also want to point out the agential aspect of it. Simply changing the structures, but retaining the same actors will not bring federalism far."
A change in the system of government requires a constitutional change and past attempts to push for federalism in the country have failed.
In support of Joint Resolution No. 10 which got the backing of 16 senators, Bacolod Rep. Monico filed the House Concurrent Resolution No. 15 in 2008.
Differing from the Senate resolution which called for the convening of Congress as a constituent assembly to amend the Constitution, the House version included constitutional convention as an option.
As mandated by the 1987 Constitution, constitutional amendments could be made through a constitutional assembly, constitutional convention, or people's initiative.
Then President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo supported the constituent assembly proposal of Pimentel.
Under this method, the Constitution states that any amendments to it may be proposed by Congress "upon a vote of three-fourths of all its members."
Many, however, saw Arroyo's push for charter change as a ploy to extend her term.
"Charter change is and has been a sensitive topic for us," Go explained. "Any attempts to introduce change is welcomed by protests and criticisms." Critics are also wary that federalism will lead to fragmentation given the ethno-linguistic divide in the country.
Many are also divided on whether it could strengthen regional communities or deepen the hold of political dynasties.
"On the one hand, federalism may indeed empower local political elites and keep their hold of power. On the other hand, the creation of state governments may pose as a challenge to political families in different localities," Go explained.
As to Cordillera autonomy and how it would fare in a federal government, Baguio mayor Mauricio Domogan said in the San Fernando conference a Cordillera Autonomous Region could co-exist in “parallel” with a federal region thus the Cordillera Regional Development Council’s thrust is “Cordillera autonomy towards federalism, but we reserve this topic for another issue. 

Read more...

‘Breakup’ of Cordillera under federal gov’t looms

>> Thursday, July 20, 2017

As CAR commemorates 30th founding anniversary 


By Dexter A. See 

BAGUIO CITY– As the Cordillera Administrative Region is celebrating its thirtieth founding anniversary this July, Mayor Mauricio G. Domogan warned of a possible breakup of the CAR once Congress, as a constituent assembly to amend the Constitution, will decide to delete provisions that mandate establishment of autonomous regions in the Cordillera and Muslim Mindanao to suit the administration’s bid to shift from the present presidential form to federal government.
The mayor said the potential breakup of the Cordillera is not a threat to those who are against the renewed quest for regional autonomy but it is a reality that can happen once a number of provinces will ratify the autonomy law once enacted by Congress and signed into law by the President and once the constitutional provisions mandating establishment of autonomous regions will be deleted during the charter change.
“We do not intend to threaten anyone regarding the possible disintegration of our region in the future once the situation warrants it that is why it is high time for us to unite to achieve autonomy as this might be our last chance to do so amidst the administration’s planned shift to federal form of government within the term of President Rodrigo R. Duterte.
He added that Cordillerans are lucky because President Duterte, through Presidential Peace Adviser Jesus Dureza, is supportive of the region’s renewed quest for regional autonomy unlike during the previous administration and Cordillerans must reciprocate the support by showing their interest in establishing the autonomous region in the Cordillera.
Domogan said Cordillerans were actually treated as second-class citizens when some parts of the CAR were parts of Region I and II during the martial law regime and people do not want the problem to be repeated once the region will disintegrate if the autonomy law is rejected or once the renewed quest for regional autonomy will be overtaken by the planned shift to federal form in the future.
Republic Act 4695 or the Division Law divided the previous Mountain Province into four independent provinces namely, Bontoc that retained the old name of Mountain province, Ifugao, Kalinga-Apayao and Benguet. However, when former President Ferdinand Marcos issued Batas Pambansa No. 1 or the decree that divided the country into regions, the Cordillera was again disintegrated wherein Benguet, Baguio city and Mountain Province went to Region I while Ifugao and Kalinga-Apayao joined Region II.

After the signing of the September 13, 1986 historic Mount Data peace agreement, former President Corazon C. Aquino issued Executive Order No. 220 that reconfigured the Cordillera Administrative Region which brought back Abra, Benguet, Baguio city and Mountain Province from Region I and Ifugao and Kalinga-Apayao from Region II to comprise the CAR. Later, the former Kalinga-Apayao area was divided into two independent provinces by virtue of Republic Act 7878. Under the provisions of House Bill 5343 or the bill that seeks to establish the autonomous region in the Cordillera, cities and provinces that will not vote in favour of the establishment of an autonomous region in the Cordillera will revert back to their original regions allowing the cities and provinces that voted in favor of the autonomy law to compose the autonomous region in the Cordillera. 

Read more...

PDP exec: Federalism balances gov’t political, economic power

>> Sunday, July 16, 2017


By Jam Malingan

LAGAWE, Ifugao – “So why federalize the Philippines? The primary objective is to balance distribution of government powers and to balance the distribution of government budget.”
Partido Demokratiko Pilipino-Laka sng Bayan (PDP-Laban) Laguna Chapter Chair, former Laguna governor Emilio Ramon Ejercito emphasized  this during the recent Ifugao 51st founding anniversary and 2017 Gotad Ad Ifugao Grand Program at the Lagawe Plaza. 
Ejercito urged Ifugao people to support push for federalism, particularly the Nene Pimentel model, which aims to balance distribution of political and economic power across the regions.
He also outlined other objectives of the federal government that includes bridging the gap between the rich and the poor, stopping Muslim rebel repression and communist insurgencies, protection of socio cultural diversity, and empowerment of the Filipino people.
He said former Senator Nene Pimentel, Senate President  Koko Pimentel, former Dept. of Budget and Management Sec. Salvador Enriquez, Dr. Jose Abueva, Justice Reynato Puno, former Vice President Teofisto Guingona, former DILG Secretary Rafael Alunan, and former Finance Secretary MargaritoTeves are among members of 25-man consultative committee formed through Executive Order 10 Series of 2016 signed by President Duterte on December 7, 2016.

The committee is tasked to create the final draft of the federal form of government for the Republic of the Philippines. --PIA CAR

Read more...

The folly of federalism redux


PERRYSCOPE
Perry Diaz   

President Rodrigo Duterte’s top legislative agenda is the federalism of the Philippines.   Actually, federalism was not the idea of Duterte, two of our national heroes, Emilio Aguinaldo and Apolinario Mabini, were the first to suggest dividing the Philippine Islands into three federal states: Luzon, Visayas, and Mindanao.
More than a half century later, former president of the University of the Philippines Dr. Jose Abueva proposed and argued that a federal form of government was necessary to more efficiently cater to the needs of the country despite its diversity.  
He said that the primary goals of a constitutional amendment is to increase decentralization, greater local power and access to resources most especially among regions outside Metro Manila which has long been dubbed as rather imperial. 
Aside from Abueva, senator Aquilino Pimentel Jr. was a prominent supporter of federalism who had advocated federalism since 2001. He saw the proposed system as a key component in alleviating the Mindanao crisis and appeasing Moro insurgents. He argued that federalism will also hasten economic development since resource and financial mobilization is upon each states' or provinces' discretion without significant constraint from the central government. [Source: Wikipedia]
During the presidential elections of 2004, president Gloria Macapagal Arroyo campaigned for constitutional reforms.  After winning the elections, she created the Consultative Commission, headed by Dr. Abueva.  The task of the commission was “to propose the necessary revisions on the 1987 Constitution that included a shift to a unicameral parliamentary form of government, decentralization of national government, and empowering local governments by a transition to a parliamentary-federal government system.”  i
The proponents of charter change, while agreeing on a parliamentary system, are divided between the supporters of Federalism and those that decry Federalism as an unworkable political system. Instead, the anti-federalist group is pushing for the adoption of a unitary parliamentary system.
Today, President Duterte is pushing hard to change the government to a federal system using the model similar to the one proposed by Abueva in 2004.  He has been pressuring the House of Representatives to pass legislation to effect a charter change.  Well, it doesn't seem as easy as it sounds. 
While a unitary government – the central government -- has all the power, federalism would seem to be more democratic. But don’t be fooled by it.  There are lots of variables and unknowns before the House could responsibly fashion the necessary amendments to fit the fundamental tenets of a Philippine democratic system as enshrined in the 1987 Constitution.     
Allow me to share excerpt from my column, “The Folly of Federalism,” which I wrote in October 2005.  I said, “To get a pretty good ‘feel’ of how Federalism works, let's look at Australia. In 1901, Australia adopted the Federal Parliament and government with the six States giving up some of their powers, but remaining independent. The Australian Constitution states, ‘The legislative power of the commonwealth shall be vested in a Federal Parliament.’ In addition, the constitution gives a range of powers and responsibilities to the Federal Parliament. Powers not identified in the constitution reside with the States.  Each of the six States has its own constitution, parliament and government.  
“But there is a lot of overlapping between the Australian Federal and the State governments. A history of competition between the Federal government and the State governments exists. Since the Federal government controls tax collection, it has established its dominance in the political system. The States became dependent on Federal financial assistance. [www.AustralianPolitics.com]
“In terms of tax collections, the website says, the Federal government gets 70-80% of all tax revenues. The Federal government then divides the expenditure of the tax revenues between the Federal and State governments. This created ongoing financial negotiations -- and haggling -- between the Federal government and the States.
“There are advantages and disadvantages of Australian Federalism.  However, the disadvantages far outweigh the advantages, some of which are: duplication of government; overlapping or conflicting policies in different parts of the country; State education systems with differing curricula and grading methods; financial inequality which leads to unhealthy competition and rivalry between the States; neglect in important areas of, to cite a few, public policy and public transportation; and over-government. The website claims, ‘It is often argued that a nation of 19 million people cannot afford to have 15 houses of parliament, plus hundreds of local governments.’
“According to a study conducted by the University of Sydney, the question was asked: ‘Has Federalism outlived its usefulness in Australia?’  The study concluded: ‘It is obvious that the advantages no longer exist and the advantages are overweighed by the numerous disadvantages. It is truly time for Australia to make major reforms for it to remain an effective government process.’ “ 
Federalism for the Philippines
Given the advantages and disadvantages of Australian-style Federalism, it begs the question: Should the Philippines pursue a Federal system of government?
In my opinion, Federalism for the Philippines is a folly. Let's look at some numbers.  
Its Gross Domestic Product (GDP) was worth $292.45 billion in 2015 and the GDP per capita was $7,725 (ranked 118) compared to Australia’s GDP per capita of $48,899 (ranked 17), the Philippines would not be able to afford the cost of Federalism.  
First of all, most of the big industries and manpower resources are concentrated in Metro Manila and its surrounding provinces, Cebu City, Davao City and a few other places. Provinces that are agricultural-based would be hard-pressed to collect taxes to maintain their government structure, which would consist of a legislative body, judicial system, education system, health professionals, law enforcement, social services and several other agencies. After the Federal government has taken its bigger share of the tax revenues, the amount left for the regional governments would not be enough to sustain their existence.
ARMM and CAR
In 1989, the law creating the Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (ARMM) was passed.  It was composed of the provinces of Basilan, Lanao del Sur, Maguindanao, Sulu, and Tawi-Tawi and the cities of Marawi and Lamitan.  The political intent was to satisfy the aspirations of the Bangsamoro people for self-rule and self-determination.  It was created to address the “Moro problem.”  But instead of solving the “Moro problem,” ARMM divided Bangsamoro into several factions run by regional warlords. 
In 1997, the Philippines passed a law creating the Cordillera Autonomous Region  (CAR), which states:  “The Cordillera Autonomous Region is a territorial and political subdivision administered by the Regional Autonomous Government consisting of the regional government and local government units under the general supervision of the President of the Republic of the Philippines.”
On paper, ARMM and CAR are ideally suited to address the “needs” of the Bangsamoro people and the cultural minorities in the Cordillera region, comprised Abra, Apayao, Benguet, Fugal, Kalinga, and Mountain Province.  However, ARMM and CAR do not have the financial independence or the ability to create revenue-generating industry.  
As a result they become pauper entities that depend on the central government for all the things they need to function as “autonomous” regions.     

 Some people argue that a Federal government is the only way to give freedom and independence to the Filipinos. In today's globalized economy, what is freedom and independence? In my opinion, freedom is "financial freedom" and independence is "financial independence." Real freedom and real independence can only be achieved with wealth and the ability to compete in the global market. If we free the Filipinos into creating their own country without financial freedom, then they will become slaves of their own country.  (PerryDiaz@gmail.com)

Read more...

Vertical integration of parallel concerns

>> Tuesday, July 19, 2016

BANTAY GOBYERNO  
Ike SeƱeres

We do not know yet what new States will emerge in the proposed federal system of government for the Philippines, but suffice it to say for now that these will most likely be formed along the jurisdictions of the existing sub-national regions.
Although there are no existing formal government structures within these regions as of now, suffice it to say also that these will be formed out of what now exists within the present Regional Development Councils (RDCs). Of course, politics is politics and the people might want something else, but it is best to prepare as early as possible, starting with what we already know.
Looking back, it is really just political gerrymandering that caused the division of the big old provinces into the smaller provinces that now exists. For example, there was just one big Davao that is now separated into several provinces.
Same goes for the old Cotabato and the old Surigao. In the case of what used to be the old Davao and the old Cotabato, I do not think the people would mind using the old names for the new States. It could be different in the case of what used to be the old Surigao, because the people there might want to keep the new name Caraga as the name of the new State. By the way, Caraga is not an acronym like MIMAROPA. Caraga is the name of an old kingdom in the area, and it could still be a fitting name for a new State.
I think that as early as now, we could already predict that there will be at least three ministerial functions that would remain at the federal level, and these would probably be foreign relations, national defense and fiscal policy.
There would certainly be a number of federal agencies that would have to be formed, but these would no longer be at the ministerial level, meaning to say without cabinet rank. That said, it is possible to prepare as early as now to build the future infrastructure for State level governance, and these should include all functions other than the prospective federal functions that I earlier named.
As it is now, the RDCs are composed of the existing Provinces, and because of that, it could be said that these Provinces are now the building blocks of what could eventually become the prospective federal States. As it is now, all these Provinces would already have the existing Departments for the delivery of public services, such as trade and industry, labor and employment, education and health.
That being the case, it would be very easy for these Provinces to contribute their existing manpower and material assets so that the Departments at the prospective State level could be formed as early as possible, in a way that they could hit the ground running.
As it is supposed to be, the lower levels of the local development councils are supposed to submit their reports to the next higher level. For example, the Barangay Development Councils (BDCs) are supposed to submit to the Municipal Development Councils (MDCs), the MDCs are supposed to submit to the Provincial Development Councils (PDCs), and the PDCs are supposed to submit to the RDCs. Some of these councils may be doing that already, but right now it is difficult to compile the reports because the data is not structured, and there are actually no databases that could store the data. If only the databases could be built, it would be easier to cause the vertical integration of parallel concerns.
I am just using the term concerns in a general sense, because that could either mean functions or datasets. What is important to note however is that the data about these concerns could be gathered from the lower levels and submitted to the higher levels, thus ensuring the collection of real empirical data, instead of just inventing data from nowhere.
For example, it would be possible to gather health data from all the barangays in a municipality so that we would really know how many people are sick, so that we would know the resources that are needed to provide adequate healthcare services. I might sound too idealistic as I say this, but this is exactly what universal healthcare is all about.
By definition, a census is not the same as a survey, because the latter simply tests a sampling of the total data universe. The more accurate data source is a census, but the problem with a census is that it is taken too far in between, and the latest census data are already stale after a few years. The solution to that is to gather current data on the fly direct from the actual sources, and that is no other than the barangay level. In theory, it would actually be possible to conduct surveys at the barangay level with the quality of a census, because the data universe at that level is small enough to cover in so short a time.
To put things in the right perspective, I am obliged to say that information is simply just processed data, and information is simply just a tool for decision making. It goes without saying that all executives at all levels of governance should have current information at hand, in order to make the right decisions.
Without current information at hand, it could even be said that these executives would be negligent of their duties if they make decisions that are not based on current information. Suffice it to say therefore that the bottom line of this equation is how serious and how sincere these executives really are in performing their duties.

I am also obliged to say that information could be gathered even without computers, if and when these executives would really want to do it, no matter what. On the other hand, these executives no longer have any excuse not to computerize, because it has become easier to do that nowadays, and the costs are no longer prohibitive. As the saying goes, if there is a will, there is a way. If these executives could not find the political will to do it, they have no right to be in public service. If for any reason they could still find an excuse not to computerize because of certain objections, I would offer to help them computerize, so that all their objections would become moot and academic. Email bantaygobyerno-subscribe@yahoogroups.com or text +639956441780

Read more...

  © Blogger templates Palm by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP  

Web Statistics